I was saddened to see that a Denial of Service (DOS) or a Distributed Denial of Service (DDOS) attack has brought down Internet services for more than 40 Millions users in the East Coast of the United States. DOS attacks are those launched across the Internet to take websites and other services off the air, often utilizing ‘bots /Botnet’ on infected home and business computers. In fact, we may sometimes be complicit and participating in the attack without our knowledge. The astonishing thing is that DOS attacks are nothing new. They have been around since the early days of the Internet.
Case and point, take for example RFC2827, which is also referred today as BCP38 (Business Current Practice 38):
The Abstract of the RFC2827 reads:“Recent occurrences of various Denial of Service (DoS) attacks which have employed forged source addresses have proven to be a troublesome issue for Internet Service Providers and the Internet community overall. This paper discusses a simple, effective, and straightforward method for using ingress traffic filtering to prohibit DoS attacks which use forged IP addresses to be propagated from ‘behind’ an Internet Service Provider’s (ISP) aggregation point.
Note: BCP38 is RFC2827: Network Ingress Filtering: Defeating Denial of Service Attacks which employ IP Source Address Spoofing.
Image from BCP38 page
Paul Ferguson and Daniel Senie wrote the above Abstract in May of the year 2000 as part of the abstract of RFC2827. As an employee at Cisco Systems where Ferguson was also employed at the time, I had reviewed RFC2827 as part of a process to include its features in the Cisco IOS Software. Yes, that was 16 years ago!
Over the past 16 years, cyber criminals have sharpened their tools to a point that today, it is really easy and very low cost to launch a DDOS attacks with impunity; helped by the fact that one can hide behind forged source IP addresses. DOS attacks, and their even nastier cousins DDOS attacks are easy to do and hard to deal with. That situation is made worse if the packets used during the attack have forged source IP addresses, which, in turn, make it harder to stop the attack because it is impossible to determine where the attack is actually coming from.
Just last year, in February 2015, theInternet Society convened a roundtable bringing together network operators, vendors, leading security experts, and researchers in this area to discuss the problem of source IP address spoofing with a goal to better understand the challenges of addressing it or help solve the problem, and to identify paths to improve the situation going forward. It seems that BCP38 can help make a dent in the arrogance of those who disrupt our lives at will. The logic is that without spoofed IP addresses, there will be no Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS) attacks.
I am not stating that BCP 38, which essentially blocks (or drops) packets from forged source IP addresses from entering the Internet will solve all DOS attacks. In fact, we know that there is a small chance that non-fraudulent packets will also be dropped and that network operators may have to handled those exceptions manually. But those efforts are a small price to pay for our protection.
Some may argue that if it is that easy, why didn’t people do it? I ask myself the same question every time there is one of these flamboyant attacks. Maybe some people don’t know they can do some thing about it. Maybe they don’t know they should do something about it. Or maybe they just don’t know. That is one of the reasons Jighi is proudly sponsoring the Ivoire Cyber Security Conference on November 9 – 10 in an attempt to educate and build a community of concerned cyber citizen.
For those who think that BCP38 is not be perfect, I say: it gives us a way to stop an attack before it causes systems to go down. It also gives us a way to track weaponized packets to their source; unlike today situation where we are left to speculate. Today’s attack, as reported by CNN simply, crippled Amazon, Reddit, Twitter, Netflix and others.
Whatever the reasons for our lack of actions, the current Cyber Space is not sustainable.Attackers have more and more sophisticated tools and we are unable to come together to tackle this phenomenon. I say, let’s give a chance to BCP38. Let’s eliminate the easy things with seemingly easy solutions: DOS attacks, and their even nastier cousins Distributed Denial Of Service attacks are easy to do and hard to deal with because of the forged IP addresses. That situation is made worse because the attack cannot be quickly stopped. Why? Because forged source IP addresses make it impossible to determine where the attack is actually coming from.
Just a quick thought on today’s event.